Feedback
Most of my positive comments were about the compositions of my postcards which I was happy about because had tried to keep the compositions simple but they were clearly effective in making the four images work as a set.
I particularly like the comment about the images being calming to look at. I did intend for them to be peaceful images because pilgrimage is a religious journey where people feel in touch with their beliefs so this comment leads me to believe that this has been successful.
People didn’t comment on the specific locations of my postcards so I am unsure whether they could pinpoint the cities or not. However, there were comments about my concept being clear and it fitting the brief so I think that the theme of my four postcards was clear and the religions and locations could probably be worked out from this information.
When reading through my criticism, the question was raised about the positioning of the statue in the Lourdes postcard. I had battles with this issue earlier in the project but eventually decided that it was more efficient to have the hands on show rather than the head because more visual symbols were visible when it was cropped in this way.
Someone also asked whether Mecca is ever as quiet as I have portrayed in my image. I do agree that Mecca is a busy place but I wanted to capture the calming feeling of a religious person feeling close to their god. I understand that maybe adding crowds of people into the background might make the location clearer but I would have to consider their position and arrangement carefully if I wanted the image to have the same peaceful atmosphere.
Evaluation
I had only ever used illustrator once before and this was only briefly so I felt very new to the software and I didn’t know a lot about the different functions. Considering I was basically learning from scratch, I think I have done well to produce these outcomes in this space of time. I felt I needed to inform myself about the subject of my postcards for the religions and locations to be represented accurately and respectfully. I found this research element interesting and I learned quite a few new things.
I think I may have wasted a little time at the beginning of this project with my drawings from reference as I was drawing things that would be difficult to transfer into vectors. I am undecided whether this actually was a waste of time or not though because a few of my final postcards had stemmed from some of my initial drawings even though they are in a totally different style. I tried to do enough roughs so that I had a clear idea of what I needed to do on Illustrator before I actually opened the program. I knew that I wasn’t very confident with the software so I wanted to have a clear plan to work to to make the work less complicated for myself. I still got a bit caught up with designing on screen which I now know is dangerous territory because there are so many options available to you. I think the main on screen alterations I made were to try and make the images work more as a set which, in the long run, has been successful.
I think colour was something I did not put as much consideration into as I could have done. I was hoping to make a clear colour palette for each postcard but I got carried away with the designing and just selected colours as I went along, judging whether they were working well or not. I tried to take inspiration from the key colours of the location and the colours of the country’s flag. For example, the Lhasa postcard has the red and yellow of the Chinese flag and I included the green of the Saudi Arabian flag in the Mecca postcard.
If I was to do this project again I would make an even more detailed plan of my images to stick to and maybe trace over more of my drawings rather than building images up from pure shape. I didn’t really like using photographs of the two buildings to trace over because I felt like it wasn’t really my work and I hadn’t put my own stamp on it so if I do a project like this again it is something I would want to avoid.